Some of page content & features are available only to members - Sign up only takes 8 seconds!

Are You Delighted by Film Noir? ...Have a Favourite?

+3 votes
May 20, 2017 in Movies by Virginia (7,565 points)
edited May 20, 2017 by Virginia

I (finally) came to love the genre when I was home ill around 2005...our tiny library on Mt. Baker had a passel of 'em! Can't really name a favourite, however...but I have learned they developed out of German Expressionism as an art form, in the existential angst surrounding WWII...

But as a toddler in the 1940's I squirmed through LOTS of them in theaters, as my parents would not entrust their precious first-born to babysitters (BORING...where's Bambi?).

But now Turner Classic Movies occasionally goes on a rampage; THE LOST WEEKEND, THE POSTMAN ALWAYS RINGS TWICE, some great old Humphrey Bogart films...I like the dark realism, the suggestion that even though life itself is awful/FUBAR, it is still worth living and even celebrating!

* * *

So please, your experience with film noir, or maybe your favourite movie(s), or just any free association that might arise for you?

4 Answers

Rooster May 20, 2017

Now you know I would have some as I watch TCM almost every evening.More favorites than I can list here!

Virginia Rooster May 20, 2017

Rooster these are wonderful, and you have given me a new suggestion because I have not yet seen WHOSE LIVES ARE CAUGHT! 

And hmmmm...looks like John Wayne is in it too!

Rooster Rooster May 20, 2017

He is! It's actually The Wake of the Red Witch! Here's another of my favorites.

Virginia Rooster May 20, 2017

omg Rooster, it is Jimmy Cagney and Virginia Mayo! If ever an actor was born into the 'right' time, it is Cagney and the gangster films...

TheOtherTink May 20, 2017

Of course:)

Two of my favorites:

The Treasure of the Sierra Madre

The Third Man

Virginia TheOtherTink May 20, 2017

I have loved both of these also, O'Tink...when I first saw Bogart in TREASURE OF THE SIERRA MADRE, I recall I could hardly believe a film could be SO well done...white knuckles and all...

Rooster TheOtherTink May 20, 2017

Good ones! 

Virginia TheOtherTink May 20, 2017

Rooster truly an unforgettable scene...

Hitman TheOtherTink May 22, 2017


Virginia TheOtherTink May 22, 2017

Hitman, I was glad to see this too...utterly funny, Harvey Korman doing his thing...

Marianne May 20, 2017
Of course, the classics of the Film Noir are great, and I still appreciate them, but I can't tell which is my favourite, as I would have to draw up a list - lol - and there are still quite a few waiting to be discovered, or rediscovered.

Virginia Marianne May 20, 2017

Dear Marianne,

These links are just superb! Especially enjoyed the second one - which is not only a list, but some fascinating psychological exploration of how noir came about, and how it continues into the present day, ty!

Marianne Marianne May 23, 2017

I am glad that I could give you some useful links.


Hitman May 22, 2017

The old Man forgot some! 

Virginia Hitman May 22, 2017

Oh Hitman, I have seen the first two but not Gung Ho...and that film certainly has some fine actors. 

War movies have not typically been something I would watch all that much over the years, but have gotten some education on that from your father...and yes, some very fine drama (as well as humour) in some of them!

Rooster Hitman May 22, 2017

@Virginia: You'll notice they are Marine movies! :D

Virginia Hitman May 22, 2017

Rooster I remember! You were Green Beret, and your offspring was a Marine...

TheOtherTink Hitman May 22, 2017

@ Rooster,

Yeah, but at least John Wayne starred in the Iwo movie.  :)

I think this one is great too:

Rooster Hitman May 22, 2017

Tink: I love that movie! <3

TheOtherTink Hitman May 23, 2017
@ Rooster,
Yes, it's a great movie. And this scene is funny, where Major Pluskat first sees the allied ships from his shore bunker. He frantically calls back to HQ, and yells, "The invasion is on! There are 5000 ships!"
HQ responds, "Keep your shirt on, Pluskat. (sips tea) The Americans and English together can't have half that many ships."
Pluskat: "Dammit, come down here and see for yourself if you don't believe me!"
HQ: "My dear Pluskat, what's their course?"
Pluskat:  "Towards me!  Direct!!"  :D

Rooster Hitman May 23, 2017

@Tink: Know the scene well! All the stars and hearthrobs of the early 60's are all in it.

Marianne Hitman May 23, 2017
TheOtherTink Hitman May 23, 2017

@ Rooster,

And the real Pluskat survived the war. There is a youtube clip of him on the Normandy beach years later, describing what he said to his superiors on D-Day.  Not exactly like in the movie, but close enough.  :D

TheOtherTink Hitman May 23, 2017

@ Marianne,

Oh yes, all these great war movies.  Thank you, Marianne!

But I don't think they can ever really make civilians understand what it is like to really be under fire or to really kill another soldier. Some veterans of combat say they didn't have time to be frightened, others say that anyone who says they weren't frightened is lying.

Nevertheless, no less a personage than Gen. Joshua Lawrence Chamberlain of the Union army in the American Civil War said exactly that (that he did not feel afraid). And he led his men from the front, as was customary for colonels and brigadiers to do in those days, and was wounded six(!) times, nevertheless surviving until 1914. And most amazing, he wasn't a professional soldier at all. He was a college professor with a remarkable natural ability for military leadership.

Virginia Hitman May 23, 2017

Me too ty Marianne...

I had not heard of THE ENEMY BELOW, a remarkable film I can tell!

Marianne Hitman May 24, 2017


You're very welcome. Indeed, many people are (were) not aware of what others have (had) to go through; they see too often glory and glamour where there is none.

Marianne Hitman May 24, 2017


I had to look the story up, because I was not sure about the title, but I saw it long ago.

Rooster Hitman May 24, 2017

@Virginia : I just watched The Enemy Below the other night!  Excellent movie! 

Virginia Hitman May 24, 2017

Okay Rooster, between you and Marianne recommendations, it is going on my list!

Related questions

Question followers

0 users followed this question.

13 Online
0 Member And 13 Guest
Today Visits : 2924
Yesterday Visits : 1464
All Visits : 9102745