Some of page content & features are available only to members - Sign up only takes 8 seconds!

Ever seen a movie that was actually better than the book?

+3 votes
30 views
Jul 23, 2017 in Movies by Rooster (10,579 points)

I read this book a while back and it was just OK. But the movie was much better and portrayed the young man as the hero he really was.


3 Answers

TheOtherTink Jul 23, 2017

The Wizard of Oz.  :)


Virginia Jul 23, 2017

Rooster, I have not. For twenty years, however, I postponed reading THE REMAINS OF THE DAY because I did not think a book could come anywhere near the exquisitely nuanced rendering of Emma Thompson and Anthony Hopkins...but THAT book was a whole new dimension greater still...definitely better than the movie!

But yes, I would guess it would be a war movie which could convey a story more powerfully than the written word...how about THE DEER HUNTER,  or SAVING PRIVATE RYAN? (I have not read those books, just making a guess.)

Marianne Jul 26, 2017

It looked, formerly, that even outstanding movies could rarely be better than the original literature, unless a film created a new story, but there have always been exceptions.

On the other hand, if referring to theatre and opera, the written stories could'nt / cannot go without the corresponding pictures or shows with acting people, custumes, speaking, miming and the surrounding scenes, and, for operas, the corresponding presentations with music and singing.

And literature went along with visual arts, like drawing, painting, sculpture, etc., or performing arts, like music, dancing, etc.



Related questions

Question followers

0 users followed this question.

53 Online
0 Member And 53 Guest
Today Visits : 2709
Yesterday Visits : 8882
All Visits : 8731587
...